What is 3P salary? How to build an effective 3P salary system

3P salary is a modern salary management method applied by many businesses to optimize work efficiency and employee engagement. This system is based on three core elements to help build a fair and transparent salary and bonus mechanism and encourage the development of individuals as well as organizations. In this article, 1C Vietnam will analyze what 3P salary is , how to implement it and the benefits it brings to businesses.

1. What is 3P salary?

3P Salary is a modern salary system in which "3P" represents three basic elements: Position, Person, and Performance. This model is designed to ensure fairness and efficiency in the company's compensation policy. Instead of paying based on seniority or qualifications alone, the 3P salary system comprehensively evaluates the value of employees' contributions through these three factors.

The 3P salary system helps businesses create a connection between personal goals and organizational goals, thereby promoting work performance and enhancing competitiveness. At the same time, this model also creates conditions for employees to clearly see the development path and income increase opportunities based on individual efforts.

2. Three components of the 3P salary system

Each element of the 3P salary plays an important role in determining the appropriate salary for employees:

• Pay for Position : This component is based on the value of the job position within the organization. The more responsibility, influence, and complexity a position requires, the higher the base salary. For example, a CFO will have a higher base salary than an Accounting Specialist due to the difference in scope of responsibility and level of influence on the organization.
• Pay for Person : This factor considers the ability, experience, skills and knowledge of each individual. Two people in the same position can receive different salaries based on individual abilities. For example, a marketing employee with 5 years of experience and professional certification will be paid more than a new employee in the same position.
• Pay for Performance : This component is related to the employee's work performance and goal completion level, usually evaluated through KPI (Key Performance Indicators). For example, a salesperson who exceeds 150% of the sales target will receive a higher performance bonus than a colleague who only achieves 100% of the target.

The 3P salary system helps create a flexible and fair salary structure and encourages employees to continuously develop themselves and actively contribute to the common goals of the organization.

>>> SEE NOW: How is total salary fund calculated?

2. How to build a 3P salary system for businesses

To successfully implement the 3P payroll system, businesses need to have a systematic and scientific approach for each component.

2.1. Building a salary framework by position (Pay for Position)

Establishing a position-based pay framework is the first step in building a 3P pay system, which requires a detailed analysis of the value of each position in the organization.

Step 1: Analyze job value. Businesses need to conduct a detailed analysis of each position's job description, clearly defining responsibilities, authority, scope of influence, complexity, and skill requirements. Factors such as management responsibilities, financial decisions, and impact on business results need to be specifically evaluated.

Step 2: Evaluate and rank positions. After analyzing, evaluating and ranking job positions according to a standard scale, businesses can use methods such as Hay Group, Mercer or a point system to ensure objectivity. The results will produce groups of positions with equivalent values.

Step 3: Survey the labor market. Conduct a survey of market salaries for similar positions to determine a competitive salary range. Businesses can refer to salary reports from human resource consulting firms or industry associations.

Step 4: Build a salary structure by position. Based on the results of the assessment and market survey, establish a salary structure with appropriate levels (grades) and steps (steps). Each position will be assigned a specific salary level with a range (range) from low to high.

Example of salary structure by position:

The position-based salary framework is the basic foundation in the 3P salary system, helping to ensure fairness within the organization and competitiveness in the labor market.

2.2. Building a salary framework based on ability (Pay for Person)

The competency-based salary framework evaluates and recognizes the value each individual brings based on knowledge, skills and work attitude.

Step 1: Identify core competencies. Businesses need to build a core competency framework for each position group, including:

• General competencies: applicable to all employees (such as communication skills, teamwork)
• Management skills: for leadership positions (such as decision-making skills, team management)
• Professional skills: specific to each job position (such as programming skills, design skills)

Step 2: Apply the ASK model. The ASK model helps to comprehensively assess employee capacity in three aspects:

• Attitude: An assessment of one's morale, motivation, and personal values.
• Skill: Ability to perform specific tasks
• Knowledge: Professional knowledge and academic background

Step 3: Build a competency assessment scale. Set up a rating scale with clear levels for each competency, for example:

• Level 1: Basic - Beginner
• Level 2: Medium - Applicable
• Level 3: Proficient - Apply Regularly
• Level 4: Excellent - Can guide others
• Level 5: Expert - Can innovate

Step 4: Link competencies to the salary structure. Each competency level will correspond to a certain allowance or salary increase rate. For example, an employee with the same position but reaching a higher competency level will receive a higher salary within the salary range of that position.

Example of how to apply salary according to ability:

A Grade 5 Marketing Specialist has a basic salary range of 15-20 million VND. Based on competency assessment:

• If you reach level 2: Receive a basic salary of 15-16 million
• If you reach level 3: Receive a basic salary of 16-18 million
• If you reach level 4-5: Receive a basic salary of 18-20 million

A merit-based salary framework not only recognizes the value of employees but also encourages them to develop themselves and improve their professional skills.

2.3. Building a Pay for Performance framework

The third component of the 3P pay system is performance-based pay, which directly links earnings to employee performance and contributions.

Step 1: Set up KPIs for each position. Each job position needs to have its own set of KPIs (Key Performance Indicators) that reflect specific goals and responsibilities. KPIs need to meet the SMART criteria (Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, Time-bound).

Examples of KPIs for some positions:

• Salespeople: Sales, new customers, conversion rates
• Marketing staff: Traffic, conversion rate, customer acquisition cost
• IT staff: Project completion time, number of errors encountered, troubleshooting time

Step 2: Determine the weight for each KPI. Not all KPIs are equally important. Businesses need to allocate appropriate weights based on priority and impact on overall goals.

For example:

• KPI 1: Sales (weight 50%)
• KPI 2: Number of new customers (weight 30%)
• KPI 3: Customer rating (weight 20%)

Step 3: Set up the performance bonus formula. Build a clear formula to calculate the performance bonus based on the KPI completion level:

Bonus calculation formula:

Performance bonus = Base bonus × (% completion of KPI 1 × weight 1 + % completion of KPI 2 × weight 2 + ... + % completion of KPI n × weight n)

Step 4: Determine the evaluation and payment cycle. Depending on the industry and goals, businesses can apply a monthly, quarterly or annual evaluation cycle. For some positions such as sales, monthly evaluation and bonus payment can be applied to increase motivation.

Step 5: Set up reward levels based on results. A scale or percentage system can be used to determine reward levels:

• Reach 80-100% of target: Get 100% of base bonus
• Reach 100-120% of target: Get 120% of base bonus
• Achieve over 120% of target: Get 150% of base bonus

Performance-based pay frameworks help motivate employees, align individual interests with organizational goals, and promote a culture of high performance within the business.

3. 3P payroll system implementation process

Implementing a 3P payroll system requires a systematic process and the involvement of multiple stakeholders in the business.

3.1. Basic implementation steps

Below is the process of implementing a 3P payroll system effectively and comprehensively:

Step 1: Analyze the current situation and define goals. Evaluate the current salary system, analyze its strengths and weaknesses, and clearly define the goals when converting to a 3P salary system. Goals may include increasing work performance, retaining talent, optimizing personnel costs, or standardizing salary and bonus policies.

Step 2: Form a project team. Build a dedicated team with representatives from HR, finance, functional departments, and management. This team will be responsible for designing, implementing, and evaluating the 3P payroll system.

Step 3: Build organizational structure and job descriptions. Review and standardize organizational structure and job descriptions for all positions. This is the basis for determining job value and building salary frameworks by position.

Step 4: Design the three components of the system in detail. Implement the detailed construction of the three components of the 3P payroll system as described above:

• Salary scale by position (Position)
• Salary scale according to ability (Person)
• Performance pay scale

Step 5: Develop assessment tools and processes. Develop tools, forms, and processes to assess employees across the three elements of the 3P compensation system. This includes a competency assessment framework, KPI dashboard, and performance assessment process.

Step 6: Simulate and test. Before full deployment, simulate and test the system with a few departments or groups of employees. Evaluate the impact of the new system on the total payroll and employee income.

Step 7: Communication and training. Develop a clear communication plan to explain the new system to all employees. Organize training sessions for managers and employees on how the 3P payroll system works.

Step 8: Official implementation. After careful preparation, officially implement the 3P payroll system throughout the enterprise. It can be applied in stages or implemented simultaneously depending on the size and characteristics of the organization.

Step 9: Evaluate and adjust. After implementation, regularly evaluate the effectiveness of the system and collect feedback from stakeholders. Adjust and improve continuously to ensure the system meets its objectives.

3.2. Important notes when applying the 3P salary model

To ensure effective implementation of the 3P payroll system, businesses need to note the following important points:

Note 1: Ensure transparency and fairness. The system should be designed and communicated transparently, helping employees understand how salaries are calculated and the factors that affect their income. Evaluation criteria should be clear, objective and applied consistently.

Note 2: Balance between the three components. Depending on the strategy and industry characteristics, the enterprise needs to determine the appropriate proportion between the three components of the 3P salary system. A common structure is:

• Position: 50-60% of total income
• Person: 20-30% of total income
• Performance: 20-30% of total income

Note 3: Ensure budget feasibility. The 3P payroll system needs to be designed within the framework of the enterprise's human resources budget. Cost simulation and forecasting are needed to ensure financial sustainability.

Note 4: Integrate with human resource development strategy. The 3P salary system is not only a salary payment tool but also needs to be linked to a long-term human resource development strategy, including promotion roadmap, training plan and capacity development.

Note 5: Take into account cultural and industry specificities. Each industry and organization has its own characteristics, so the 3P salary system needs to be adjusted to suit the specific context. Do not mechanically apply models from other businesses without adjustment.

4. Challenges when applying the 3P salary system

Despite bringing many benefits, the application of the 3P payroll system also faces many challenges that businesses need to identify and have appropriate solutions.

4.1. Common problems

When implementing the 3P payroll system, businesses often encounter the following challenges:

Challenge 1: Difficulty in objective assessment. Competency and performance assessment can be affected by the subjectivity of the assessor, leading to unfairness and reducing the effectiveness of the system. In particular, the factors "Person" and "Performance" are often difficult to measure accurately and objectively.

Challenge 2: Complexity in management and operation. 3P payroll systems require more complex databases and management processes than traditional payroll systems. This can create administrative burdens and increase management costs.

Challenge 3: Difficulty in communication and consensus building. Many employees familiar with the old salary system may resist or not fully understand the new system, making it difficult to implement and build consensus.

Challenge 4: Inappropriate KPI quantification. Setting inappropriate KPIs can lead to undesirable work behaviors, such as focusing on quantity at the expense of quality, or a lack of collaboration between departments.

Challenge 5: Salary budget fluctuations. The “Performance” component can cause fluctuations in the salary budget, especially when many employees are performing at the same time, increasing unexpected personnel costs.

4.2. Solutions to overcome challenges

To address the challenges of applying the 3P payroll system, businesses can apply the following solutions:

Solution 1: Develop a multi-dimensional evaluation process. Apply a 360-degree evaluation method with the participation of many stakeholders (superiors, colleagues, subordinates, customers) to minimize subjectivity. At the same time, standardize evaluation criteria and train evaluators to ensure consistency.

Solution 2: Apply technology in management. Use specialized human resource management software to automate the evaluation process, calculate salaries and track KPIs. This helps reduce errors, save time and increase transparency.

Solution 3: Implement an effective communication strategy. Develop a clear communication plan using multiple channels (team meetings, emails, instructional videos) to clearly explain the benefits and how the 3P payroll system works. Organize training sessions and workshops to answer questions and collect feedback from employees.

Solution 4: Design balanced and comprehensive KPIs. Build a set of KPIs that balance short-term and long-term goals, and quantitative and qualitative targets. At the same time, design group KPIs and individual KPIs to promote cooperation between departments and employees.

Solution 5: Establish budget control mechanisms. Develop salary budget scenarios with different scenarios and establish limiting mechanisms to control total costs. For example, apply a performance bonus adjustment factor based on the overall business results of the enterprise.

Solution 6: Implement in phases and evaluate continuously. Take a step-by-step approach, starting with a few pilot departments before expanding to the entire enterprise. Regularly evaluate and adjust the system based on feedback and actual results.

With the above solutions, businesses can overcome challenges and optimize the effectiveness of the 3P payroll system, thereby creating a fair, transparent and performance-boosting working environment.

5. FAQs – Frequently asked questions about the payroll system

5.1. Is the 3P payroll system suitable for small businesses?

The 3P salary system can be applied to small businesses, but it needs to be adjusted to suit the size and resources. Small businesses can apply a simplified version with fewer salary levels and a simple evaluation process. The benefits of applying this system are that it creates a basis for sustainable development, attracting and retaining talent from the early stages of development. Small businesses should start with simple tools such as Excel spreadsheets and apply it step by step, prioritizing the factors that are most important to the company's development strategy.

5.2. What is KPI? What is the role of KPI in Pay for Performance?

KPI (Key Performance Indicators) are key performance indicators used to evaluate the level of goal completion of individuals, groups or organizations. In the 3P compensation system, KPI plays an important role in the Pay for Performance component.

KPIs help:

• Specify goals and expectations: Help employees understand what needs to be achieved
• Objective Measurement: Provides an objective basis for evaluating performance
• Linking compensation to results: Creating a basis for calculating performance-based compensation
• Create motivation for improvement: Encourage employees to continuously improve their work results

Effective KPIs need to ensure SMART criteria (Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, Time-bound) and need to be reviewed and adjusted periodically to match the business strategy.

5.3. Which industries are most suitable for applying the 3P salary model?

The 3P salary model can be applied in many different industries, but is especially suitable for:

• Finance - banking industry: Working environment with specific measurable results (sales, number of customers) and high requirements for professional competence, very suitable for all three elements of the 3P model.
• Information technology industry: Requires continuous updating of knowledge and skills (Person) and has projects with clear KPIs (Performance), and has a clear hierarchy of positions (Position).
• Retail and customer service: Performance can be easily measured through sales, customer reviews, and has many levels of positions from employee to manager.
• Manufacturing industry: Can apply clear KPIs on productivity, product quality, and have a clear hierarchical organizational structure.
• Consulting industry: High demand for expertise (Person), projects with measurable results (Performance), and clear hierarchy from consultant to partner (Position).

Factors that help determine appropriateness include: the ability to measure performance, the level of hierarchy in the organization, and the importance of individual competencies to job outcomes. However, this model needs to be adjusted to suit the characteristics of each specific industry.

3P Salary is a modern and effective salary system, helping businesses build a fair, transparent and aligned salary and bonus mechanism with organizational goals. Through three core elements - Position, Person, Performance, this system not only ensures competitiveness in the labor market but also promotes the development of employees and the organization. Successful implementation requires careful preparation, appropriate methods and support tools.